AI Top 8

I thought tonight was decent.  Not quite “inspiring”, but better than other weeks have been.

Michael Johns – I thought he sounded great and disagreed with Randy about him impersonating a rocker.  It was confident,  strong performance.

Kristy – It was a great performance.  Probably one of her best.  But for me, she doesn’t seem like the winner.  Does anyone else agree they should do something different to her hair?  It looks dated and not “done” enough.  I know, nothing to do with her singing, but just a side note.

Jason – I love this song.  Of course, I think it is from the ending of one of my all-time favorite movies, You’ve Got Mail so he couldn’t really go wrong.

Syesha – I just couldn’t get over the Fantasia factor although if I had heard Syesha sing it first, I would have thought it was great.

Carly – Not happy at all with that.  Completely agree with Simon it came off angry.

David C. – Worst performance yet.  He was too cocky and just sounded bad.

David A. – Great song, great sound, A+.  That said, I don’t know if I’d actually buy an album of his.  Sort of like Clay Aiken for me.  I thought he sounded great, but I’m just not into his music.

Brooke -It was nice.  She needs to get over the nervous thing though.  She appears to be less professional and I think that hurts her at this point.

Who will go?  I think Carly is in trouble.

Favorites?  Michael Johns and Jason Castro followed by David A.