AI Top 6

I really don’t want to post about tonight for some reason. Really, I’m not a big Broadway guru and I don’t think I really have the appreciation for these songs like I should. I did see Cats though just to redeem myself a little.

Syesha – After her practice session I kept waiting for something funky and it all came out sexy. And I didn’t care for it. Yes, we all know Syesha can sing but once again, I don’t think she’s pop star quality. Maybe those who appreciate Broadway more than I could appreciate her performance.

Jason – Poor Jason. Like me, he was clueless. And unfortunately it showed throughout his performance. I however didn’t hate his song.  Although he was nervous I think he was trying to show that emotional connection.  I think if no one had every heard that song they’d love it sung the way he did it.

Brooke – Wow. That took some guts to stop the band on a LIVE show. I think it was ok but it just makes me laugh thinking of the time my mom had our local TV show in to film a commercial of her for her business and she messed up and told the guy to cut the scene. I think Heather said they all kind of froze and were like, uh, you can’t do that. Anyway, I don’t think vocally Brooke was good but I really think she connected emotionally.

David A – It was great seeing him turn something more modern and I really liked it. Again, don’t think I would buy a rhey-chord (as Simon would say) with that on it but he sounded good.

Carly – She owned the stage tonight and I think she did fabulously. Probably my favorite of hers.

David – I LOVED this. He’s definitely the one to beat.

I think Brooke and Jason are in trouble this week and I’m going to have to go with Brooke because she was in the bottom 3 last week.

To see more thoughts on tonight’s episode, go to BooMama’s site.