AI Top 5

Um, can we just get rid of round 1 and pretend it never happened? I didn’t really like anyone’s song.

And I MUST comment on Paula’s commenting. Oh my, what a mess-up. She seemed out in la-la land. Did they not discuss what was expected of them? Is she even watching the show? I thought you sang twice already?? That woman is something, I tell ya.

As for the last round..

Jason – I love me some Jason Castro. I will absolutely love his album. I could listen to him forever. But tonight was just ok. I think he’s in real danger tonight.

David Cook – I really liked this song. I think he’s good at picking songs that will make the ladies swoon.

David A – Hm, he’s getting a little boring to me. He’s a great singer for sure. No doubt. But I’m thinking his age his hindering him at this point. He’s still not doing well at taking compliments. He seems so nervous he’s about to cry.

Brooke – I liked this second performance. Do I think the vocals themselves were fantastic? No, but I saw more of a happy Brooke tonight and although her first song was way too low for her and choppy and just sort of weird to me, it was good to at least see her not about to break down in tears. I like happy, fidgety brook over teary-eyed fidgety Brooke.  I don’t know, I just think Brooke came out fighting tonight.

Syesha – I’ve been saying this for weeks. She’s boring to me. But tonight she wasn’t boring. Tonight she was old-fashioned to me. I just don’t see her as the American Idol.

Best tonight by far was David Cook.

I think Syesha might go.

Go to BooMama’s for more opinions.