Casey – His first song was average. Quality singing but just not memorable. His second one I thought he seemed so vulnerable it came across nervous. But, I think that’s a great type of song for him to do. I love Casey and all his Texas-ness but I’ll be disappointed if he makes it in the top 2.
Crystal – I think she did Come to My Window justice. I prefer the original for sure but Crystal didn’t sacrifice it. She blew the second one out of the water. Wow, I didn’t think her voice could get any better but that was amazing.
Lee – Both his songs were outstanding. I was a little disappointed when they announced Hallelujah. It’s so overdone on Idol but really, it was gorgeous. They definitely gave him the star treatment with the choir. But what I love is that Lee is finally taking it all in and really gets it that he could win this thing.
Should go: Casey
Should win: Lee
Lee's performance of Hallelujah was The Moment they're always talking about.
That song is overdone, and I don't even like Lee… but if last night was the finale he'd be winning.
O.o Lee FTW. I <3 him.