I went for coffee with Dani and totally forgot Idol was on tonight. Definitely not back in the habit of watching something live every week yet. But, don’t get me wrong, the time with Dani was way better and I’m glad I went. In any case, here are some quick thoughts!
Reed – Reed is too full of himself. His gyrations are weird and so are his facial expressions. His voice is beautiful and his take on the song was unique. I don’t know, I just can’t handle his performance.
Adam – I felt like this was a bad song choice and came across cheesy. Which is a shame because I love his story and want him to do well.
Deandre – *sigh* I love his falsetto but it did not come across well on stage. I couldn’t understand half of what he was singing.
Colton – Colton is a smart man. Singing a song from Twilight? He knows his audience. And really? Did we know Colton could perform like that? What a pro! I’m impressed. He’s no Paramore but Colton is definitely on the right track to be the American Idol.
Jeremy – Totally bored. Sorry, Jeremy, you seem really sweet.
Aaron – Felt like he was off pitch. Just not a good sound.
Chase – Felt like that was a bad song or he just didn’t have the umph to sing it.
Creighton – I’ll be honest, Creighton scares me a little. But tonight I felt like his performance was reserved yet unique and beautiful.
Phil – Phil!!! Yay! He totally pulled it off. Great song choice. He sounded awesome. Did you see Jennifer giggling after his performance? That was basically my reaction. LOVED IT.
Eben – That song is way too big for Eben. Felt a little like I was at a high school talent show. I mean, technically Eben I think is good, it’s just not enough power…or years behind him.
Heejun - Aw, I loved his clips with his family and friends. So funny! But sadly, this song was not good for him. His performance was underwhelming too. Sad face.
Joshua – Chills! I got chills from that performance! He is awesome!!
Jermaine – Sadly I think they should not have given him a call back. I’m just not a fan of his voice.
Favorites tonight: Joshua, Phil, Colton
In trouble: Deandre, Jermaine, Reed
What’d you think??
I was a little disappointed that the judge’s comments were so mild. Even I could hear that Eben’s performance was weak (and that is saying a lot!) and the judges didn’t really make a big deal out of it. Phil is my definite favorite — and his dad in the audience … So sweet!