American Idol Top 8

Paul – I thought this song was a lot of fun and I love Paul but I think his days are numbered.

Jac0b – the last three noted deserve any praise he gets. Beautiful!

Scotty- Ok I called it weeks ago that he sounded like George and while I liked it something was off with him last night. Did Pia freak them out? He seemed super nervous. It was the first time I’ve seen him unsure. Or was that his attempt at emotional vulnerability?

Lauren I’m a fan of the original but Lauren did some really cool things with it. Imma fan.

Haley – I fast forwarded most of her. Again with the overt sec appeal. How old is she anyway?

Stefano ok vocally I was a fan. But good gracious why does his face have to look like someone is twisting a knife in his back?

James – I like that James sticks to his guns on songs. While I’m not a metal fan I certainly can appreciate good vocals and a good performance. He won’t win idol doing that every week but I think it’s enough to get him through.

Casey -Again, we got The Casey Abrams and I love every second.

In trouble. I keep putting Stefano and he’s continually in the bottom but never goes. I’m still calling it and putting Paul as backup.

Favorites: Lauren, Casey, Jac0b’s last three notes