• Skip to content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Amy J. Bennett

Extraordinary Faith for Everyday Life

  • Home
  • About
  • Archives
  • Feathers Podcast
  • Entangled eBook
  • Disclosure

American Idol Top 24 Review

February 24, 2012 by Amy

Alrighty, folks, I can’t help it.  I’m going to be blogging American Idol this season.  Have you heard the Top 24?  I honestly think this is the most talented group we’ve seen yet.  It’s pretty unbelievable. 

I thought I’d pick a Top 10 from the 24.  It’s not 100% voice on these votes.  As you know, people vote for personality too so I’m doing the same.AMERICAN IDOL: TOP 24 SEMIFINALISTS: The top 24 Semifinalists are chosen on AMERICAN IDOL airing Thursday, Feb. 23 on FOX. CR: Michael Becker / FOX.

The Guys

Phil Phillips – Here’s my thing with Phil.  Every time he goes up to sing, you’re not entirely sure he’s going to pull the thing off.  He’s inconsistent.  But.  You can tell he’s made to sing.  I love how the music just explodes from him.  And he’s as cute as he can be.  Confident yet humble.  He really is a contender if he can pull off his best every week.

Joshua Ledet-  Joshua is not my normal pick but every time he sings, I’m enthralled.  I’m sure it’s the gospel vibe I’m connecting with but really?  Have you ever heard someone sing a Hallelujah that pretty?

Heejun Han – I think I have a little crush on Heejun.  He. is. hilarious.  Between his crush on Jennifer Lopez and his hatred of the cowboy, I’m just not sure I could take anymore.  What I love most is he has no clue how good he is.  Wait, wait.  I love, love that he works with special needs kids.  Oh my word, he might not be an American Idol but I think I want to be his friend.

Deandre – His falsetto is to die for and if he can just pick the right songs every time, he’s golden.

Creighton – Creighton loves himself a little too much or maybe he overcompensates because he doesn’t but I can’t deny his performance ability and voice.  He’s got the gig down already.

The Girls

Shannon Magrane – She’s got the look and wowed me with her final audition song.

Baylie Brown – She’s like cookie cutter American Idol.  I mean, seriously, if you had an American Idol machine, I think she’s what would pop out.

Elise Testone – Elise is another professional.  She’s not afraid of the stage and knows how to work it.  I think she’ll do really well in on the big stage.  She’s just not American Idol cookie cutter material.  Not really sure the voters will take to her.

Jessica Sanchez – Her voice as a lot of power and I may as well say it since we’ll hear it all season…and she’s only 16!

Jen Hirsh – Jen is amazing.  I’m just afraid her personality doesn’t have the IT factor.  I’m not saying she’s not super sweet.  I’m just not sure it will take her all the way.

Honorable mentions go to Brielle and Hollie.  Brielle has way too much attitude and Hollie I’m not sure has enough.

OK, anything can happen on that Idol stage but those are the ones I’m keeping my eye on.  Which do you like?

Filed Under: tv Tagged With: american idol

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. jamie says

    February 24, 2012 at 2:48 pm

    I have to admit I’m watching this year. But only because my friend Chelsea has made the top 24. My vote is obviously with her.

    • Amy says

      February 24, 2012 at 2:49 pm

      Not joking she was next on my list! How fun to have a friend on there!

  2. Poppy says

    February 24, 2012 at 10:57 pm

    I *love* Heejun. I doubt he will win, but if he showed up at my door and sang a few songs I’d swoon for a minute.

    • Amy says

      February 25, 2012 at 11:51 am

      Me too, Poppy. For real.

Primary Sidebar

Feed Twitter Facebook Email Feed Feed

Welcome


Hey! I'm so glad you're here. I'm Amy, working mom of 3 in the Southern suburbs. I love Jesus, my family, books, chocolate and coffee. I write about faith, parenting, adoption, marriage, fashion, and design. Read more here

The Podcast

Feathers

Feathers

Feathers

  • Search
  • Categories

Popular Posts

WIWW

WIWW

WIWW

Follow Me on Instagram

Load More...Follow on Instagram

Hear My Carolina Accent

Copyright © 2025 · Infinity Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in