Deandre: I did not enjoy this in the least. I felt like I was laying poolside and the band was playing down at the end of the pool instead of my bed. So much cheese and I just don’t think it showed his voice at all.
Erika: Holy wow. Her hair is different. I think this is a great song choice for her. Really showed off her range. I think she pulled off the right attitude.
Joshua: I just love his voice and conviction so much. Perfect song choice for him. And how do people not know that song? Wow.
Skylar: While I feel like she picked the right song I’m not quite sure I liked the arrangement. I think she needed to stick a little closer to Garth Brooks’ version than she did. I’m surprised she said that’s who she was copying after.
Elise: I think it was an awesome song on her. I feel like that was just her style. Just not sure it will connect with voters since it’s so unknown.
Phillip: I love Phillip. I say it every week but I seriously cannot quit smiling when he’s on stage. I love that he’s so consistent. I was worried before the season he might not be but he’s really proving he’s got it for the long haul.
Hollie: I felt like she was pushing it too hard and the bad notes were distracting. Just not her best.
Heejun: Well, I feel like we’re on borrowed time with Heejun. That was super fun but maybe not a winning performance.
Jessica: She really did sing that beautifully. Not my favorite song ever but she really proved once again how big that voice is.
Colton: Loved this. Just perfect for him.
Favorites: Colton, Phillip, Elise, Jessica
In trouble: Heejun, Deandre